Working title: What organises collective music? Rules, Control, and Interdependence in Interactive Music-Making

Where the question starts

Two experiences. One is collective music-making in everyday life where I grew up: work chants, circle dances at harvest, folk bands at rituals. There, people seemed to know when to join, when to stop and whom to follow, with no score and no announced rules. The other is my own installations, most recently Between Tree and Concrete. There I hand part of the control to visitors, but I connect each of them only to the system and to me, not to one another.

From both comes the question in the title: what was organising the music? The thesis narrows it to something a designer can arrange: which aspects of sound each person can change, and how those changes depend on other people’s actions.

Main research question

How do rules and arrangements of control set conditions for collective music-making, and how do participants recognise and use these conditions?

Conditions means the possibilities, limits and choices that rules and arrangements of control set for participants: who can change what, which results depend on others, and when one can act. Recognise and use means how participants understand these conditions through textual, sonic, visual and bodily cues, and how they respond to each other on that basis.

Subquestions

SQ1 — Where dependence is placed. Where do scores, interactive instruments and sound installations place dependence between participants, and how is it carried out?

SQ2 — Control and agency. How does access to control relate to the choices that remain with participants and to their musical agency?

SQ3 — Cues. Through which textual, sonic, visual and bodily cues do participants recognise these conditions, and how do they respond to each other through them?

SQ4 — Closeness (exploratory). How do participants’ accounts of closeness or distance relate to their mutual responses?

Connection between people remains the artistic concern behind all four. The research approaches it through how participants respond to each other and, as an exploratory question, through their sense of closeness or distance.

Scope

  • Co-located. Several people physically present in the same room, making sound together
  • Novices. Participants need no experience of the kind of music-making involved, or of the system; musical background and familiarity with the interface are counted separately
  • Music as the shared outcome, not a by-product of another task
  • Relations between people. What happens between each person and the system is not the focus
  • Cases range from text scores to interactive instruments and sound installations, compared with existing studies of how they are used. See Related Works
  • Making. Approached through Research through Design: a two-person prototype, Interdependent Instrument, played by ten co-located pairs. The pairs differed in musical background and in how well the two people knew each other. Each session combined an interview with closeness ratings; see Prototype Sessions

Key terms

TermAs used here
Collective music-makingActivities in which several people take part in producing or shaping sound and music. Used as the umbrella term for the setting
Co-presencePeople can perceive one another and know they are perceived in turn (Goffman, 1963). It is stronger than simply being co-located; see Embodiment and Co-presence
Musical coordinationHow participants organise their actions in relation to one another while making music: taking turns, aligning timing, and adjusting to what they hear. See Coordination and Interdependence
Musical agencyParticipants’ capacity to make musical choices, step into the unfolding sound, and understand their own contribution. See Musical Agency
Sense of agencyThe felt experience of controlling one’s own actions and their effects (Moore, 2016)
Mapping and feedbackA mapping specifies how an input changes an aspect of sound. Feedback is what participants can perceive about an action or a change in the system

Where the interest comes from is in Starting Point, earlier formulations are in Log, the concepts in use are in Concepts, and every reference is in References.

Status

Working formulation, unchanged since 2 November 2026 and confirmed in the 14 November draft. The wording is close to final. Submission is in December 2026.

The thesis itself is not published here before submission — this site records what the research uses, not what it argues.

0 items under this folder.