Pacherie (2012), The phenomenology of joint action · Bishop (2018) · Zhou et al. (2023)
Two modes. Pacherie distinguishes “we-agency, where self-boundaries and sense of self-agency appear to dissolve into the collective, and shared agency, where self-agency and joint-agency are articulated rather than fused” (2012). Taking self-agency as a baseline gives three steps rather than two.
Hard to measure. Reviewing collaborative musical creativity, Bishop notes that emergence “requires comparing the combined output of an ensemble to the output that individuals would produce if performing their part alone” (2018), and that systematic empirical studies testing such models are largely absent.
Not just synchrony. Zhou et al. (2023) had pairs tap either a fixed pitch sequence or a duet with metrical and harmonic relations between the parts. At similar levels of synchrony, the duet produced a stronger sense of joint agency — the musical relation between the partners’ actions mattered, not only their timing.
Used here as the collective half of the agency question, alongside musical agency.