Hattwick & Wanderley (2012), A Dimension Space for Evaluating Collaborative Musical Performance Systems, NIME · doi:10.5281/zenodo.1178281

What it is. A dimension space for describing one configuration of a digital music ensemble, often specific to a single composition or installation. It is modelled on Birnbaum et al.’s dimension space for musical devices, and several axes are taken from Weinberg. Each axis is a pair of limits plus the questions that place a configuration on it:

AxisLimitsAsks
Texturehomogeneous / heterogeneousHow discernible are the individual parts?
Equalityequal / unequalIs there a leader? Do players have access to the same data?
Centralizationcentralized / decentralizedIs information shared through a central server? How important are global parameters such as tempo?
Physicalityfixed / freeAre players in the same space? How much do visual contact and entrainment matter?
Synchronysynchronous / sequentialIs information shared in real time, or turn by turn?
Dependenceindependent / interdependentCan a performer make sound without input from the others? Do they share control of a musical event?

The axes describe the character of a collaboration; they do not rank it. The authors offer two uses: evaluating existing configurations, and finding under-explored ones to design.

A six-axis star diagram labelled texture, equality, centralization, physicality, synchrony and dependence

image: Hattwick & Wanderley, NIME 2012, fig. 1 (CC BY 4.0)

Used here as a source for the dependence dimension: whether a person’s sound depends on someone else’s input.